Norfolk Southern Settles East Palestine Derailment Lawsuit For $600 Million

Norfolk Southern plans to pay residents and businesses $600 million to settle a class-action lawsuit over a February 2023 train derailment in East Palestine, Ohio.

Norfolk Southern plans to pay residents and businesses $600 million to settle a class-action lawsuit over a February 2023 train derailment in East Palestine, Ohio.

Still pending court approval, the settlement does not contain any admission of liability or wrongdoing from the rail company.

The agreement would resolve class action complaints within 20 miles from the site of derailment, and personal injury claims within 10 miles.

Thousands of residents were forced to evacuate from the East Palestine area after the derailment, which preliminary reports suggested was caused by a faulty wheel bearing on one of the train’s freight cars.

Settlement payment recipients would be able to use the money as they see fit. But some residents worry that the settlement money would be minimal when divided among all claimants, according to the Associated Press.

Norfolk Southern made national headlines last year after approximately 50 of its freight cars derailed while containing toxic chemicals like vinyl chloride. Used in many plastic products, this chemical is carcinogenic and fatal to many animal species.

After the derailment, rail workers set chemicals in the freight cars on fire to prevent their spill. But the National Transportation Safety Board later deemed these burns — which set tens of thousands of gallons of hazardous materials ablaze — unnecessary.

The derailment and subsequent burning prompted an outpouring of environmental and health concerns from local residents.

Attorneys representing Norfolk Southern told the Associated Press that the settlement funds aim to offer residents and businesses relief after the derailment and subsequent year of investigation.

To date, Norfolk Southern has spent more than $1.1 billion responding to the incident, which the United States Environmental Protection Agency said did not constitute a public health emergency last week.

Environmental and health concerns associated with the derailment extended to West Virginia, with the state border located less than 20 miles away from the incident.

Concerns stemmed from the derailment’s proximity to the Ohio River, a waterway that forms West Virginia’s western border and directly touches 12 different counties.

Gov. Jim Justice said in February 2023 that state officials had not detected a dangerous concentration of chemicals in the state’s drinking water following the derailment.

Scott Mandirola, deputy secretary for the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection, also said that water samples collected from the Ohio River contained low concentrations of the chemical butyl acrylate, but that they did not pose a threat to public health.

Mandirola said that air quality tests in West Virginia’s Northern Panhandle likewise did not suggest the presence of threats to public health.

Meanwhile in Washington, D.C., the derailment’s aftermath spurred promises of train safety reform and, this year, a new policy for train crews.

Last week, the Federal Railroad Administration announced all domestic trains must have a crew of at least two members. The policy was first developed under the administration of former President Barack Obama, but was pushed forward by the derailment in East Palestine.

While the new policy begins to take effect, the Norfolk Southern settlement will await a final court decision before settlement payments are initiated.

The settlement plan could be submitted for court approval as early as this month, and settlement payments could begin before the year ends, according to the Associated Press.

Reporters Discuss ‘Women’s Bill of Rights’ Legislation On This West Virginia Morning

On this West Virginia Morning, Briana Heaney and Emily Rice spoke with Lori Kersey, a reporter from the independent news organization West Virginia Watch. One of the big stories on Friday from the statehouse was a bill called the Women’s Bill of Rights.

On this West Virginia Morning, we regularly invite reporters from outside news organizations onto our program The Legislature Today to discuss what they are seeing during the state legislative session. On Friday, Briana Heaney and Emily Rice spoke with Lori Kersey, a reporter from the independent news organization West Virginia Watch. One of the big stories on Friday was the bill called the Women’s Bill of Rights.

Also, in this show, it’s been a year since the Norfolk Southern train derailed in East Palestine, Ohio, releasing chemicals and resulting in the burning of vinyl chloride. Some residents are still worried about chemicals inside their homes. But as The Allegheny Front’s Reid Frazier reports, the EPA won’t do indoor testing.

West Virginia Morning is a production of West Virginia Public Broadcasting which is solely responsible for its content.

Support for our news bureaus comes from Shepherd University.

Eric Douglas is our news director and producer.

Listen to West Virginia Morning weekdays at 7:43 a.m. on WVPB Radio or subscribe to the podcast and never miss an episode. #WVMorning

Capito: Rail Safety Bill Will Pass, But Not Until Next Year

Nearly 10 months after a train derailment resulted in a release of toxic chemicals in East Palestine, Ohio, Congress has still not moved forward with legislation.

U.S. Sen. Shelley Moore Capito says Congress will pass a rail safety bill, but there’s not enough time to do it this year.

Nearly 10 months after a train derailment resulted in a release of toxic chemicals in East Palestine, Ohio, Congress has still not moved forward with legislation.

Capito, a member of the Senate Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee, says some areas of disagreement remain on the bill the committee approved earlier this year. She voted no.

With government spending bills on the line, border security, as well as support for Ukraine and Israel, the issue has fallen down the list of lawmakers’ priorities.

Capito says the differences can be worked out and predicts a bill will pass.

“I would say it’s going to be happening,” she said. “It happens next year.” 

The Feb. 3 Norfolk Southern derailment was traced to a broken wheel bearing. Thousands were evacuated from the small town near the Pennsylvania border, and emergency response teams from three states came to fight the fire.

The railroad made the decision to vent and burn cars full of vinyl chloride, resulting in plumes of thick, black smoke that darkened the sky. The incident generated nationwide attention, and angry lawmakers brought Norfolk Southern CEO Alan Shaw in front of Congress to testify.

The legislation Congress is considering would require more safety inspections, automated defect detectors, improved training for first responders and notification of hazardous materials shipments to local officials. A provision requiring a minimum crew size of two is part of the dispute. The train in East Palestine had three crew members on board.

Groups Petition EPA To Regulate Coal Dust From Trains

The Sierra Club and other organizations submitted a petition for rulemaking this week to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

Environmental and public health groups want to require railroads to prevent coal dust from escaping from trains.

The Sierra Club and other organizations submitted a petition for rulemaking this week to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

They want the EPA to regulate the coal dust that comes off trains. Coal-hauling railroads, including Norfolk Southern and CSX, would be required to seek permits under the Clean Water Act.

The landmark law has never been applied to transporting coal by rail. Railroads have been transporting coal in open-top cars for more than a century. Some treat coal loads with chemical compounds to prevent dust from blowing off.

Coal dust and particles can contaminate drinking water and aquatic life, the groups say. 

They also say the dust can pollute the air, increasing the risk of asthma, bronchitis and heart disease. 

In 2019, the Association of American Railroads, the industry’s principal lobbying group, anticipating potential regulatory action, filed a petition with the U.S. Surface Transportation Board to exempt coal dust from trains from the Clean Water Act. 

The following year, the agency declined to grant the exemption.

2 W.Va. Shortline Railroads Get Federal Funding For Upgrades

The Appalachian & Ohio Railroad and the Kanawha River Railroad will receive as much as $16 million and $19 million, respectively.

The U.S. Department of Transportation is giving two West Virginia shortline railroads money for improvements.

The Appalachian & Ohio Railroad and the Kanawha River Railroad will receive as much as $16 million and $19 million, respectively.

That’s from the Federal Railroad Administration’s Consolidated Rail Infrastructure and Safety Improvement Program, made possible by the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021.

The two railroads will use the money to rehabilitate track, locomotives, bridges and tunnels.

The Appalachian & Ohio operates 158 miles of track between Grafton and Cowen and hauls primarily coal. It interchanges with CSX.

The Kanawha River Railroad operates 385 miles of track from Columbus, Ohio, to Elmore, West Virginia, and hauls coal, chemicals, cement, aggregates and metals. It interchanges with Norfolk Southern and CSX.

The two awards are part of USDOT’s $1.4 billion total investment for 70 projects in 35 states.

Trust: East Palestinians Not On The Same Track

In this episode of Us & Them, host Trey Kay hears from residents who face daunting challenges. Some say government agencies are doing their best at ongoing cleanup, while others say delays and inconsistent information leave them uncertain about their safety and unclear about whether they can go home. 

In the aftermath of a disaster, people search for assistance and answers. 

Since a rural Ohio train derailment sent toxic material into the air, soil and water earlier this year, people in East Palestine have needed help. Some look to the government for that support, while others aren’t sure who to trust. 

In this episode of Us & Them, host Trey Kay hears from residents who face daunting challenges. Some say government agencies are doing their best at ongoing cleanup, while others say delays and inconsistent information leave them uncertain about their safety and unclear about whether they can go home. 

This episode of Us & Them is presented with support from the West Virginia Humanities Council and CRC Foundation.

Subscribe to Us & Them on Apple Podcasts, NPR One, RadioPublic, Spotify, Stitcher and beyond.


An East Palestine, Ohio resident watches a black plume rise over his town, in February 2023, after a controlled detonation of derailed Norfolk Southern tank cars filled with vinyl chloride.

Credit: NPR
Until the Norfolk Southern derailment, Jami Wallace was an East Palestine resident. She lived just over a mile from the accident site. Now, she’s moved with her family to East Liverpool — about 30 minutes away. She has a law degree and a background in Political Science and Public Administration. Now, as president of a response group for her community — the Unity Council — she finds herself a de facto spokesperson for a town still in crisis.

Credit: Trey Kay/West Virginia Public Broadcasting
A yard sign near the center of East Palestine.

Credit: Trey Kay/West Virginia Public Broadcasting
Macklain Hersman works in IT and says he lives within the official disaster area. He has history in East Palestine. In fact, his house has been in the family for three generations.

Credit: Trey Kay/West Virginia Public Broadcasting
Mark Durno, an EPA response coordinator, takes questions from concerned East Palestine residents.

Courtesy Stephanie Elverd
EPA Community Involvement Coordinator Diane Russell discusses the air monitoring data that the EPA has collected for the East Palestine area.

Courtesy Stephanie Elverd
“East Palestine is quite a conservative area, but what I saw whenever things happened was I saw people who were on the right, who were on the left, who were somewhere in the middle, and some people who didn’t care at all, come together to demand answers and demand justice. Personally, I was proud of that, and that’s part of the reason why I’m here…that beauty in coming together, that solidarity, is what everyone should have all the time.” — Timothea Deeter, East Palestine resident

Credit: Trey Kay/West Virginia Public Broadcasting
Exit mobile version