Justice, Staff Say State Police Probe Will Intensify

Gov. Jim Justice said Wednesday that public statements made by resigned State Police Superintendent Jan Cahill that he was blindsided by the investigation and he followed protocol across the board are false.

Gov. Jim Justice said Wednesday that public statements made by resigned State Police Superintendent Jan Cahill that he was blindsided by the investigation and he followed protocol across the board are false.

“It holds credence that we discussed those claims in my driveway,” Justice said. “Beyond that, I don’t have any earthly idea how it holds any credence.”

Cahill spoke Tuesday on MetroNews Talkline. The former Greenbrier County Sheriff, who Justice appointed to lead the State Police in 2017, said his role in multiple State Police wrongdoing investigations were misrepresented or distorted. 

Cahill said he took no action on a video camera installed in the State Police Academy’s women’s locker room showers because the perpetrator was dead when he found out about the incident and that it happened before his tenure. He said that the one woman caught on video tape wanted the matter closed, a thumb drive with the video was destroyed, so, there was no perpetrator, no evidence, no accuser, no victim and no required action   

Cahill made the public statement that a senior trooper caught on camera taking an envelope of money dropped by a patron out of the Mardi Gras Casino was exonerated by casino and lottery investigators. He said that he couldn’t fire the trooper because he retired after the incident. Cahill questioned whether the money was allegedly stolen, saying he “picked up unclaimed property.” 

Justice said the trooper money grab was stealing, pure and simple. 

“This is not somebody stealing copper out of the lines way back up Whoo Hoo Hollow, this is a police officer stealing money,” he said. 

In the briefing, Justice’s Chief of Staff, Brian Abraham, questioned Cahill’s leadership abilities. 

“The only way you maintain your credibility is through the integrity you demonstrate and then being transparent,” Abraham said. “It appears that all efforts were taken down there to try to keep things from people that were not good news, keeping it concealed in an effort not to demean their reputation. He did not understand the roles and responsibilities associated with being the superintendent of the State Police.”

Abraham said Cahill mishandled the women’s locker room camera probe.

“When he became aware in 2020 that there’d been a videotape involving members of his staff, even though one was deceased, there were others that destroyed key and relevant evidence, yet suffered no investigation or any discipline for that misconduct,” Abraham said.

Abraham said Cahill shirked his duties in not firing a senior trooper who allegedly stole money at the Mardi Gras Casino, noting both legal precedent and state code shows Cahill had complete authority to dismiss the trooper.

“With regard to the incident at Mardi Gras he indicated that he didn’t have the authority to terminate the trooper for misconduct and that that absolutely is not correct,” he said.

Abraham refuted Cahill’s claim that he was the fall guy and victim of vendettas.

“Colonel Chambers has now taken over,” Abraham said. “He’s resolved to have matters reinvestigated and determine whether there was misconduct.” 

Abraham said investigations into old and new State Police misconduct charges would be reopened, continued or commenced. 

Newly appointed interim State Police Superintendent Lt. Col. Jack Chambers said in the briefing there are multiple things going on that will be addressed, including personnel.

“I’m going to look at every position that is disappointing in the State Police and evaluate those,” Chambers said. “I have to get some information from everybody first, but I can’t give you a timetable.” 

Abraham said several matters have been turned over to federal authorities. 

State Police Superintendent Resigns Amid Investigations Into Women’s Rights Violations, Stealing, More 

An investigation found evidence of videotaping a State Police women’s locker room, stealing money at a casino and a concerning I-81 crash investigation.

In a video press conference Monday afternoon, Gov. Jim Justice announced he accepted the resignation of State Police Superintendent Col. Jan Cahill early that morning.

An investigation found evidence of videotaping a State Police women’s locker room, stealing money at a casino and a concerning I-81 crash investigation.

Justice said, “The more we dug, the more it stunk, you can’t make this stuff up.”   

A Department of Homeland Security probe began with an anonymous letter listing allegations of State Police wrongdoing. 

“When you absolutely think that a women’s locker room ought to be an absolute safe place, we’ve got a situation, whether it was in 2014 or 2016, whether it was before Jan (Col. Jan Cahill), before the governor or whatever it may be, our State Police did stuff that was really bad,” Justice said. “We put a video camera in the women’s locker room. To me, it is absolutely intolerant, not to be tolerated in any way.”

Justice said the invasion of women’s privacy got even worse regarding destruction of evidence, after the unnamed individual who planted the camera died of a heart attack.

“There were three troopers that found a thumb drive and from that they found the video,” Justice said. “Then from what I understand, one, if not all, immediately jerked a thumb drive out and threw it on the floor and started stomping on it. Now we’ve got law enforcement officers destroying evidence.”

Justice said the investigation also found videotape evidence showing a State Police trooper committing theft at the Mardi Gras casino in Cross Lanes.

“There was a man playing one of the video machines,” Justice said. “There was a state trooper close by. In some way, the man got up and an envelope that he had fell out in the seat. I think he went on to the restroom. There’s no way to look at this other than just this, the trooper picked it up and took the money. Basically, that money was stolen. And then as far as doing a quick investigation and getting right on to what we should get onto, we didn’t do that.”

Justice said a third investigation is still underway involving State Police trooper involvement in a fatal accident on Interstate 81.

“We’ve had an individual loss of life on I-81,” Justice said, “I’ve seen the video. The video is very, very concerning. The investigation is ongoing at this time.” 

Cahill, the former Greenbrier County Sheriff, had been State Police Superintendent since the Justice administration took office in 2017. Justice said Cahill asked around midnight Sunday to talk. They met in Justice’s driveway on Monday morning.

“The first thing I told Jan was there is no pathway here,” Justice said. “There is no pathway that absolutely you can remain as the colonel of the State Police in the state of West Virginia.”

Justice said he has appointed Capitol Police Lt. Col. Jack Chambers as interim State Police Superintendent and said Chambers will work with Department of Homeland Security Secretary Jeff Sandy to further investigate the locker room and casino incidents. 

“Jack Chambers is a man of honor,“ Justice said. “He’ll do the right things and we entrust upon him to absolutely do any level of rightness, clean up, whatever it may be, we will entrust upon him to do just that. As I promised you, it’s got to go further than that, and here’s where there are many areas of allegations and Jack Chambers will absolutely address those allegations.”

The governor’s Chief of Staff, Brian Abraham, said other allegations regarding the State Police are still under investigation. Justice said federal investigators are already looking at these incidents and that Chambers will work with Secretary Sandy and the governor’s office to restore trust and integrity to the West Virginia State Police. 

Will A New Legislative Makeup Affect W.Va.’s Greyhound Racing Industry?

In 2023, West Virginia will be the only state left with greyhound racing. Industry opponents say a new legislative makeup could end the sport here. Proponents say it’s stronger than ever.

In 2023, West Virginia will be the only state left with Greyhound racing. Industry opponents say a new legislative makeup could end the sport here. Proponents say it’s stronger than ever.

Grey2KUSA is a non-profit dedicated to ending Greyhound racing in the United States. Executive Director Carey Thiel said after Tuesday’s vote, West Virginia anti-Greyhound racing legislators now make up a majority, and will likely reintroduce a bill to eliminate the sport.

“I would say to lawmakers who are looking at this, we believe the votes are likely there in both chambers at this point,” Theil said.

Del. Shawn Fluharty, D-Ohio, is a long-standing Greyhound racing supporter. He calls Theil’s group a “propaganda machine” and has doubts about any proposed Greyhound elimination bill.

“Nobody has an idea of what the appetite would be for such legislation,” Fluharty said. “People have seen beyond his lies and misinformation and realize that this industry is thriving. It produces thousands of jobs and millions in revenue.”

Theil said the facts are not on Fluharty’s side. He said dog racing profits are down and most realized revenues go to out-of-state internet gambling outfits.

“I think the legislature should ask itself, ‘do we really want to be the last state to allow an industry that is resulting in a large number of dogs being hurt?’” Theil said.

Fluharty argued that greyhound racing profits are better than ever for a sport that he said is both humane and beneficial.

“You’ve got to look at this industry and see how many dogs who retire from racing become adopted,” Fluharty said. “It’s better than your local shelters.”

West Virginia is bound by law to support the Greyhound racing operations at two casinos, Wheeling Island in Ohio County and Mardi Gras Casino and Resort in Kanawha County. Theil hopes to end an annual state subsidy of about $17 million that the Greyhound racing industry has received each year for many years.

Fluharty said the industry payments are not a subsidy. He explained that the funds come from other casino profits and are filtered by the state back to Greyhound breeders and racing operatives — with no taxpayer money involved.

The Delaware North corporation owns both West Virginia’s Greyhound tracks. Back in May, a spokesperson said patrons and profits continued on a five-year decline and the company would support legislation to run its casinos without greyhound racing.

For extensive background and insight on the Greyhound racing industry in West Virginia, check out WVPB’s special series, Greyhound Racing In W.Va. – Last Of A Dying Breed.

Greyhound Racing Nearing Its End In The US After Long Slide

The greyhounds are racing again in Dubuque, Iowa, but after a shortened season ends in May, there will be only three tracks left in the country. Later this year, that number will dwindle to only two, both in West Virginia.

Vera Rasnake laughed as she led a trio of barking, jostling dogs into the Iowa Greyhound Park, but her smile faded when she acknowledged that after 41 years of being around the sleek animals, her sport was teetering on extinction.

After the end of a truncated season in Dubuque in May, the track here will close. By the end of the year there will only be two tracks left in the country.

“It’s very hard for me to see this,” Rasnake said.

It’s been a long slide for greyhound racing, which reached its peak in the 1980s when there were more than 50 tracks across 19 states. Since then, increased concerns about how the dogs are treated along with an explosion of gambling options have nearly killed a sport that gained widespread appeal about a century ago.

A racing association found that betting on greyhounds plunged from $3.5 billion in 1991 to about $500 million in 2014. Since then, many more tracks have closed.

In some states like the dog-racing mecca of Florida in 2021, it was voter initiatives that ended the sport at the state’s dozen tracks. In others like Iowa, state officials allowed casinos to end subsidies that had kept greyhound racing alive as interest declined.

“Do I think the industry is dying? Yes,” said Gwyneth Anne Thayer, who has written a history of greyhound racing. But “it’s happening way faster than I thought it would.”

The Dubuque track closure and the end of racing in West Memphis, Arkansas, this December will leave racing only in West Virginia, where tracks in Wheeling and near Charleston operate with subsidies from casino revenue.

For some animal welfare groups, the industry’s collapse is the culmination of decades of work to publicize allegations of greyhound mistreatment. The group GREY2K was formed in 2001 and Carey Theil, the organization’s executive director, said he feels a sense of accomplishment now that the sport’s end seems within reach.

“This has become one of the signature animal welfare debates of our time,” Theil said.

GREY2K, the Humane Society and other groups have long argued that greyhound racing was cruel, including its longtime practice of killing dogs that weren’t deemed top racers, using drugs to enhance their performance, confining them for long periods and subjecting animals to the risk of injury on the racetrack.

Industry supporters note there now is a huge demand to adopt retired racers and deny that the other problems are widespread. They also contend that some don’t understand the love greyhounds have for running.

On opening day at the Iowa Greyhound Park in Dubuque, spectators packed into a spacious room that overlooked the track, sipping beers and mixed drinks as they pored over racing statistics before placing bets at kiosks or with attendants. They expressed disappointment that the track would close, lamenting the loss of an entertainment option in Dubuque, a city of about 60,000 known for its stately brick buildings and church steeples built on hills overlooking the Mississippi River.

Peggy Janiszewski and her friend Robin Hannan have for years been driving about three hours from the Chicago area to Dubuque to watch the racing. They typically bet only a few dollars on each race but are more interested in watching the dogs than counting their winnings.

“They’re beautiful. Like works of art,” Janiszewski said.

Bruce Krueger said he has been making the 170-mile (274-kilometer) drive from Milwaukee to Dubuque. He doesn’t believe the dogs are mistreated.

“I know some trainers, and they treat them like kings and queens,” Krueger said.

General Manager Brian Carpenter was 16 when he started working at the track in its second year and has remained 36 seasons until this, its final year.

He recalls the excitement when the track opened in 1985, a time when Iowa was mired in farm bankruptcies and much of Dubuque was struggling. Back then, thousands of people would attend the races, with buses of gamblers arriving every weekend from Chicago and Milwaukee.

“It was an exciting time and the track offered good jobs,” he said.

Opening day this year drew at least 1,000 people but smaller crowds are typical, especially on weeknights.

The Dubuque track was helped along by city and state funding, and after Iowa and other states began allowing casinos, the Dubuque operation was expanded to include its own casino.

Thayer’s book, “Going to the Dogs — Greyhound Racing, Animal Activism, and American Popular Culture,” describes a sport with a colorful and often tumultuous history. From its beginning in the 1920s following development of the mechanical lure — typically a stuffed bone or stuffed animal that swiftly clatters around the track ahead of the dogs to attract them — the industry was continually pushing to allow for legalized betting state-by-state and to attract attention, with help from Hollywood celebrities, athletes and beauty pageant competitors.

At times, the sport drew more spectators than its more prominent rival horse racing. While considered seedy by some, it was mainstream entertainment for decades, Thayer said.

“People don’t realize how normalized it was in American culture for a long time,” she said.

Greyhound racing also is held in other countries, including Australia, Great Britain, Ireland, Mexico and Vietnam, but it is facing some of the same problems apparent in the U.S.

Although greyhound racing in the U.S. will be confined only to West Virginia, that state seems intent on retaining the sport, said Steve Sarras, president of the West Virginia Kennel Owners Association. The state’s two tracks run races five-days a week year-round.

Sarras said West Virginia legislators made repeated visits to his kennel and others to inspect conditions, and ultimately were confident the dogs are well treated.

“When you see it firsthand, you cannot fake how happy a dog is,” he said.

___

Follow Scott McFetridge on Twitter: https://twitter.com/smcfetridge

Blackjack Player Who Left Casino to Rob Bank Gets Prison

A drug-addicted gambler who left a West Virginia casino, robbed a bank, then returned to the blackjack table was sentenced Thursday to between five and 18 years in prison.

Kerry Johnson had been at the Mardi Gras Casino in Nitro for hours Aug. 2 when he put down a $25 chip to hold his spot. Prosecutors said Johnson then drove 13 miles to a Charleston bank and gave tellers a note saying he had a bomb and a weapon and robbed it of about $5,000.

Johnson then returned to the blackjack table and resumed gambling.

Police later found Johnson at his home asleep on a couch. Prosecutors said a large sum of cash was stuffed between couch cushions, and some taken during the robbery was recovered at the blackjack table.

Johnson had said he’d taken quite a few drugs on Aug. 2 and “most of the day was a blur” but recognized himself after seeing video from the bank.

While a public defender had sought home confinement, Kanawha County Circuit Judge Duke Bloom said Johnson needed to be punished for his “extraordinarily risky behavior.”

“We also need to send a message to the community that bank robberies are not acceptable,” Bloom said.

Friends described what Johnson did as bizarre and out of character. Johnson earned $300,000 to $400,000 a year as a car salesman and dealership consultant, and he said he made “so much money that it never ran out, and it just fueled my addictions.”

Johnson told the judge he had been using drugs for more than two decades and, although he had gone into rehabilitation once, his addictions continued and “the money has been lost in gambling.”

“I am no bank robber. I’m no thief. I’ve never stolen anything my entire life,” Johnson said. “I’m a bad drug addict. I’m an addicted gambler, and I’m asking for your help. I want to get better.”

Public defender John Sullivan sought to have Johnson serve his sentence at his mother’s home in another county a mere 100 yards from a state police post. Johnson said his worst fear was losing his aging mother while he was in prison.

Johnson, 52, who pleaded guilty in January to second-degree robbery, was given credit for seven months already served in jail.

Union to Vote on Revised Insurance Proposal at Casino

Union workers at Mardi Gras Casino and Resort in Nitro plan to vote this week on a revised health insurance proposal.

The Charleston Gazette-Mail reports that during talks Tuesday with the United Steelworkers Local 14614-F9, casino management agreed to remove contract language that would have allowed future policy changes in the workers’ health insurance.

Union staff representative Heather Anderson says the casino remained firm on reducing its contributions to employee health care coverage costs to 75 percent, down from the current 90 percent. The union sought an 80 percent coverage rate.

Anderson says the modified proposal will be up for a union vote on Friday.

Last week the union rejected the resort’s previous insurance offer and authorized a strike.

The union represents about 350 Mardi Gras employees.

Exit mobile version