Site icon West Virginia Public Broadcasting

State Auditor Federally Indicted For Bank Fraud, Stealing Land

Published
Chris Schulz
A man sits at a wooden desk with his arms clasped in front of him, head resting on hands. He stares at the camera with a look of mild concern.

Mark Hunt, pictured here in 2023 during his time as a state Senator, was indicted by a federal grand jury for abusing his role as state auditor to steal nine tax delinquent properties for an associate.

Your browser doesn't support audio playback.

State auditor Mark Hunt is charged alongside three individuals working in his office of scheming to steal multiple properties to benefit a longtime friend and business associate through the improper issuance of tax deeds by his office. 

The three indicted in the alleged land theft are: 

  • David Keith Cole, 57, of Charleston, deputy chief of staff for the state auditor’s office and the office manager of Hunt’s private law firm;  
  • Frederic Scott Caudill, 59, of Charleston, general counsel for the West Virginia State Auditor’s Office; and 
  • Robert Lisle Johns, 66, of Charleston, the longtime friend and business associate, and special counsel at the state auditor’s office. 

The indictments alleges that Johns sought to purchase nine tax-delinquent properties in Kanawha and Boone counties.   

Despite determination by multiple career employees within the state Auditor’s Land Division that all nine properties were legally ineligible for deed issuance, Hunt personally signed and issued all nine deeds. As a result of the scheme, the defendants stole the nine properties from their lawful owners, the indictments allege. 

Caudill and Cole both allegedly made materially false statements to Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) agents during interviews in October. 

Hunt, Cole and a fourth individual Marie Ann Hoffmann, an employee of the state auditor’s office, are also charged with bank fraud. Those charges allege Hoffman submitted falsified government timecards so they included hours she worked at Hunt’s private law firm. Hoffman was paid state wages for her work at the private law firm with Hunt’s knowledge and after Cole validated and approved her falsified government timecards, the indictments allege.   

U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia Moore Capito said Monday the allegations are particularly serious because they involve the office entrusted with overseeing the finances of the state.  

“The notion that an elected official would feel so empowered to be cavalier about the application of what is rather clear law, I think is disappointing to me as a West Virginian, quite frankly,” he said. “I think we expect our public officials and those that lead this state to do so with not only transparency and candor, but with integrity.”  

Lawmakers had already called for an investigation into Hunt after the deed issue came to light last week via reporting by West Virginia Watch. Late last month, MetroNews reported on the existence of a grand jury after the state Auditor declined a request for records due to their being before a federal grand jury. 

“Public officials are entrusted to serve the people, not use their offices for personal benefit,” Capito said. “When there is evidence that trust has been violated, our office will follow the facts and enforce the law, regardless of title or position.” 

Monday House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, R-Clay, said in a statement that the allegations “cast a long shadow over the Office of the State Auditor and its role of maintaining the integrity of other state and local officials.” He called for Hunt’s immediate resignation.  

“Auditor Hunt should immediately resign from his office. If he resolves to do otherwise, the House of Delegates will take swift action in January to restore integrity to the Office of the West Virginia State Auditor.” 

Capito and Hanshaw both stressed that an indictment is an allegation, and all defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law. 

Del. Tristan Leavitt, R-Kanawha, raised the call for Hunt’s resignation last week. 

“There was no opportunity for the auditor’s office to go ahead and deed this property, but Mark Hunt did it anyway for a friend of his, and he was the one that personally signed all nine deeds, showing that he had personal knowledge of it,” he told WVPB Nov. 9. 

Hanshaw was swiftly joined in his call for resignation Monday afternoon by other state officials, including State Treasurer Larry Pack. 

“West Virginians deserve a government that is fully transparent, accountable and works for the betterment of our state,” Pack said. “State Auditor Mark Hunt should resign immediately so these charges do not overshadow our efforts to make West Virginia a better place to live, work and raise a family. The people of the Mountain State deserve better, especially from their elected officials.” 

The West Virginia Democratic Party’s Vice Chair Pam Cline said “The indictments have destroyed the public’s ability to trust the current leadership of the Auditor’s Office. Resignation is necessary to protect the integrity of the office.” 

Party Chair Del. Mike Pushkin, D-Kanawha, called for Hunt’s immediate resignation and commended Capito’s office for their swift work. 

“The West Virginia State Auditor’s job is to investigate waste, fraud and abuse across state agencies—not to be the creator of waste, fraud and abuse,” Pushkin said. “For Mark Hunt to remain in office under these circumstances would be like leaving the fox in charge of the henhouse. Mark Hunt, David Cole, Frederic Caudill, Marie Ann Hoffmann and Robert Johns should resign their public positions immediately.”  

Exit mobile version