Whistleblower Lawsuit Settled Against a West Virginia Agency

A lawsuit filed by two former West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources employees who said they faced retaliation for whistleblowing has been settled.

Former department executives Susan Perry and Jennifer Taylor filed a lawsuit in 2012 against the agency’s former acting secretary Rocco Fucillo, deputy secretary Warren Keefer and Bryan Rosen.

The lawsuit alleged Perry and Taylor were fired after raising issues with the agency’s handling of bids.

Court documents state a notice of mediation was filed in the Kanawha Circuit Court in February, but didn’t include settlement amounts.

The state Supreme Court ruled April 2016 that Judge James Stucky erred when he dismissed the plaintiff’s earlier suit. The justices ruled, while whistleblowing claims will go forward, Stucky was correct in dismissing others.

State Raises Penalty for Punishing Whistleblowers

A revised West Virginia law will increase the possible civil fine from $500 to $5,000 for government employers who threaten or retaliate against whistleblowers.

The measure passed by the Legislature and signed by Gov. Jim Justice also authorizes firing them instead of the possible six-month suspension under current law.

It clarifies that the fines are owed by the violators themselves, not their agencies, and says a court finding of a violation will be considered official misconduct and can be used for termination.

The law prohibits firing, threatening or retaliating against a worker for making a good faith effort to report about wrongdoing or waste.

House Passes Its First Bill of 2017 Legislative Session

The House of Delegates voted on its first bill of the 2017 state Legislative Session Wednesday – one of many ethics bills expected to move through the chamber this year.

House Bill 2006 increases the penalties for someone who violates West Virginia’s Whistle-Blower Law.

The law protects a public employee who comes forward to alert authorities, or blow the whistle, on an employer who’s involved in an illegal activity. If that employer retaliates against the employee for doing so, current law says they could be suspended from work and also be expected to pay a fine of up to $500.

The newly passed bill, however, strengthens those penalties and makes it possible to terminate the employer from his or her position and also pay a fine of as much as $5,000.

Delegate John Shott of Mercer County is the House Judiciary Chair.

“It also makes it clear that this is a personal fine against the person that up to $5,000 fine is a personal obligation of that person and not of the entity; the governmental entity that employs that person.”

The bill also puts the control for making the decision regarding termination in the hands of the public agency instead of a judge.

House Bill 2006 passed 98 to 0.

House Bill Would Strengthen Whistleblower Protections

Leaders in West Virginia’s House of Delegates say they plan to strengthen a number of ethics laws in West Virginia this legislative session. The first piece of legislation making its way through that chamber this year is House Bill 2006, increasing penalties for violating the state’s Whistle-Blower Law.

A whistleblower is someone who notifies the authorities when a person or organization they work for is involved in some kind of illegal activity. West Virginia’s Whistle-Blower Law protects a public employee from retaliation after coming forward about abuse from his or her employer.

House Judiciary Chairman John Shott, of Mercer County, is the bill’s lead sponsor. He says the penalties currently on the books for an employer who violates this law – or retaliates against the employee doing the whistleblowing – is a fine of up to $500 as well as a suspension from his or her job for up to six months. But Shott says House Bill 2006 changes that.

“It gives them a greater penalty, and it also increases the monetary penalty from $500 to $5,000, but it takes it out of the hands of the judge except to make a finding, and puts it back in the hands of the public agency to take the action against the offender,” Shott said.

The bill makes it clear that the offender would have to personally pay the fine. Instead of the six month suspension, the bill gives the public agency the option to completely terminate any employee who tries to discourage or punish a whistleblower.

“A person who reports misconduct or waste should not be retaliated against,” Shott said, “and this just strengthens the protection of those people so they feel comfortable coming forward if the penalties for someone who retaliates against them are strengthened.”

Delegate Barbara Evans Fleischauer, of Monongalia County, is the Minority Chair for House Judiciary. She says she thinks the bill is a great improvement, adding her name to the legislation as a co-sponsor.

“If we have somebody that comes forward and says there’s fraud, there’s abuse going on, and then they’re retaliated against, I think they’re doing something that helps the public, and so I think that making the person who is retaliating personally liable is the way it should be,” Fleischauer noted, “The taxpayers shouldn’t have to cover the cost of the fine. I think it’s a really good bill.”

Fleischauer says this bill is an example of how legislators can work in a bipartisan way to create better policy in the state.

Chairman Shott says this ethics bill will be one of several to come before the House this session.

West Virginia Whistleblower Lawsuit Dismissed

A lawsuit filed by two former Department of Health and Human Resources employees for raising concerns about an advertising contract has been dismissed.

Kanawha Circuit Judge Jim Stucky granted the DHHR’s motion for summary judgment last week.

Former DHHR deputy secretary Susan Perry and former general counsel Jennifer Taylor filed a whistleblower lawsuit against the DHHR in 2012.

Taylor, Perry and former DHHR spokesman John Law were reassigned in July 2012 after they objected to the handling of a six-figure advertising contract. They were eventually fired.

The Charleston Gazette reports Stucky’s dismissal order says Taylor and Perry “were engaged in wrongful conduct” when they intervened in the contract.

Judge Won't Reinstate Ex-W.Va. DHHR Administrator

A former Department of Health and Human Resources administrator has lost a bid to be reinstated before her lawsuit against the agency is completed.
 
Former deputy secretary Susan Perry and former general counsel Jennifer Taylor each filed whistleblower lawsuits against the DHHR in 2012. They alleged that they were wrongly placed on leave after they raised questions about the scoring of bids for an advertising contract.

Both were later fired.
 
The Charleston Gazette reports that Perry’s lawyer, Walt Auvil, asked Kanawha County Circuit Court Judge James Stucky on Friday to reinstate Perry and grant her back pay before her lawsuit is completed. Stucky denied the request.
 
Perry contends that former acting DHHR secretary Rocco Fucillo didn’t have authority to fire her because lawmakers never approved his appointment.
 
 

Exit mobile version