West Virginia senators have voted down a proposal to cap punitive damages from civil lawsuits in the state.
On Wednesday, two Republican senators broke party lines to help Democrats kill the measure in a 16-18 vote.
The proposal would have capped punitive damages from lawsuits at $500,000 or three times the compensatory damages, whatever is greater.
Republican Sens. Chris Walters and Daniel Hall voted against the bill alongside Democrats.
The bill was one of several legal reforms being pushed by the newly minted Republican legislative majority.